"Stop crying!" doesn't work

Carlotta Cerri

6 febbraio 2020

Stop crying!

I often hear parents say it to their visibly distressed children at the play ground, probably also to show other parents that they’re taking action. I’ve said it myself to my own children more than I care to admit, because their crying can push all my buttons at once.

But really, DOES IT EVER WORK? Do they ever stop crying, when you tell them like that? And is that really the message you want to send your children—that crying and showing their emotions when they’re sad or upset is something they shouldn’t do?

Close your eyes for a second and imagine YOURSELF crying, feel the sadness that those tears bring with them. Now imagine your friend pointing his finger at your face and saying, “Stop crying!” (which really means, “your emotions are not important to me”). How do you feel?

Close your eyes again, feel the same sadness, imagine the same tears. Now imagine your friend sitting next to you, and saying, “Breathe, I’m here when you’re ready” (which also means, “I value your emotions, and I have time for you”). Doesn’t this make you feel better?

Now think of your children crying (for whatever reason or “non-reason”), screaming, visibly distressed and confused, because emotions are confusing: what kind of friend do you want to be for them?

Be that friend.

Accedi alla conversazione (è gratis!)

Parla di questo post con il team La Tela e tutta la comunità e unisciti alle conversazioni su genitorialità, vita di coppia, educazione e tanto altro.

Unisciti Accedi

Carlotta

Ciao! Sono Carlotta, creatrice de La Tela e viaggiatrice a tempo pieno insieme alla mia famiglia, Alex, Oliver ed Emily.

Conosci Carlotta

Ti consiglio anche

Altri contenuti che potrebbero interessarti.

The 5-4-3-2-1 game to manage emotions

When I feel that anxiety takes over, I breathe and play the 5-4-3-2-1 game.

Let's stop saying "be good" to a crying baby

At the market. A mom holds her 6 months old baby boy while buying veggies. He observes everything, all the colors, it’s a sensorial explosion, he’s mesmerized, focus, calm. He’s in his natural state: sensorial exploration and learning.As soon as she puts him back in the stroller, he starts crying. She gets nervous, and promptly says to everybody: “He’s been good until now” and to the baby, “Be good! Why are you like that now?”.Why?Because from inside the stroller, the sky is grey, there’s not...

4. Quando i bambini non dormono…

In questo episodio (che a livello emotivo è stato più difficile da registrare di quanto mi aspettassi) vi racconto che cosa ho scoperto dal periodo in cui mi lamentavo di Oliver che si svegliava ogni 3-4 ore e dai primi 2 anni di vita di Emily che mi hanno fatto scoprire la vera privazione del sonno. E anche di quel momento in cui pensai di aver scoperto come far dormire tutti i bambini del mondo (povera illusa!) :-D

Children at the restaurant: let's recalibrate expectations

Let's talk again about the NOs we say to our children. Let's talk about their hysterical reactions when we say them.Most NOs we say to our kids are a product of the way we were raised and we often say them because we believe that children should be able to comply with behavioural rules decided by a society that rewards immobility: the more a child is still and silent, the better-behaved he is. The more they move and can't control their instincts (aka the more they're normal children) the more...

Using fear and threats to control children is never right!

“Stop doing that, or I’ll call the police”, “Don’t go there, or a monster will get you”.Although we were raised hearing these sentences, and might think they’re innocent, the flow of emotions and memories they bring with them in the long term is harmful for our children: it teaches them that fear is a tool to manipulate people, it teaches them to blindly listen to authorities instead of using their critical mind, and once they learn the truth (it’ll happen sooner than later) it teaches them n...

11 dicembre 2019

What it means to us to have a highly sensitive child

I sometimes share our struggles with Oliver and his bad days, I even wrote a post on the subject (you can find it here), but there’s something else I never shared with you, and it’s something that has helped me a lot understand Oliver.About three years ago, looking for answers about Oliver’s recurrent and unpredictable bad days, Alex and I read a book “The Highly Sensitive Child” by Elaine Aron, and immediately a lightbulb went on in our heads. Even though I’m not one for labels, we instantly...

22 settembre 2019

The crocodile brain

Il cervello coccodrillo ci ha aiutati a visualizzare l’emozione e domarla.

3 settembre 2019

What children need

We sleep all together in one room. We have done it for a long time, way before we started traveling. People say, kids need to get used to sleep in their room. Kids need to learn to sleep by themselves. Kids need to learn to fall asleep by themselves. I used to be one of those people.Oliver slept in his own room when he was 4 months old. We practiced sleeping on his own. We practiced falling asleep by himself. We practiced falling asleep without the boob when he woke up at night. We did all I ...

The hardest year of my life (aka what sleep deprivation did to me)

I half wrote this post LONG time ago, over 8 months ago, but it never seemed the right time to publish. I’m not more ready now, I’m still on a rollercoaster of emotions, and I still don’t see the light at the end of this sleep deprivation tunnel, but I’m stronger and more confident. So I decided to finish it, and here it goes. There’s no real advice this time, no trick, no solution, and probably it’s not even coherent. Just a mom opening up.I haven’t slept more than two uninterrupted hours fo...

7 febbraio 2016

NOTE two years later: I tried exactly the same with my second daughter, Emily, but it never worked with her, so as soon as I realized she would cry for hours, I decided to let go. This is proof that every child is different and that there are no universal methods or model experiences: we must always listen to our own maternal instinct.Emily is very different for Oliver. To this very day, Oliver needs some alone time to reflect upon things, sometimes while crying. Maybe that’s why this method ...